CCI members shutdown meeting in protest


The Department of Natural Resources’ (DNR’s) citizen oversight board, the Environmental Protection Commission, voted today to maintain a 100 pounds per acre limit on the application of liquid manure on soybean ground, a bad environmental practice that Iowa State University studies show increases the amount of nitrates in water by 19 percent.

Nearly two dozen members of Iowa Citizens for Community Improvement (Iowa CCI) testified for a full ban on the spreading of manure on beans and protested the EPC decision, forcing EPC chair David Petty to adjourn the meeting with only half the agenda completed.

“I’m a corn and soybean farmer and putting manure on ground going to soybeans is ridiculous,” said George Naylor, an independent family farmer and CCI member from Churdan, Iowa.  “Beans won’t use the nitrogen so it will enter the surface and ground water.  If manure was applied the year before corn, there will be plenty of phosphorus and other nutrients for a soybean crop already in the soil.  We need to ban the application of liquid manure on ground going into soybeans.”

Studies presented by Iowa State University scientists at the EPC meeting today clearly stated that the current limit of 100 pounds of liquid manure per acre of soybeans increased nitrate runoff into water by 19 percent.

Iowa has more than 572 polluted waterways, and there have been more than 800 manure spills in the last 15 years, according to DNR records.

A 2007 study by the Iowa Policy Project stated that factory farm manure “may be the largest agricultural polluter of Iowa’s streams and lakes”.

60% of Iowans say “we need stronger laws to stop factory farms from polluting our air and water,” according to an September 27-29 telephone poll of 572 active voters conducted by Public Policy Polling.

Who spoke in favor of the ban:

Dozens of Iowa CCI members, the Iowa Sierra Club, the Iowa Environmental Council, and a representative from the Des Moines Water Works, the largest municipal water treatment system in the state.

Who spoke in against the ban:

Iowa Farm Bureau, Iowa Soybean Association, Iowa Pork Producers, Iowa Corngrowers Assoc.

Now it’s not a battle of farmers and against environmentalists. Several CCI farmers spoke out in favor of the common sense ban.

It was a battle of corporate ag profits against the common good.


 Learn more

Join the fight


Click LIKE and TWEET if you think the EPC made the wrong decision today.

What were you doing five years ago?

Gearing up to get in the fields to take out crops? Enjoying the start of fall football? Reading up on how we could be facing a huge banking collapse that could wreck the global economy?

It’s hard to remember back five years, but I remember one thing you did:

Five years ago, Iowa CCI members pushed the Environmental Protection Commission (EPC) to consider a rule to ban the application of liquid manure on beans.

It was a good rule and an important and easy step to prevent manure in our waterways. Even our opponents had to agree that science was on our side. But, the Dept. of Natural Resources (DNR) and EPC didn’t want to act too fast so they implemented a reduction in the application rate of liquid manure from factory farms onto bean ground, with the promise of coming back in five years to look at more science and public comment before making a final decision on the ban.

It’s five years later. The EPC will be considering the full ban at tomorrow’s meeting.

Can you take three minutes right now to remind the EPC how important this rule is?


Five years later and the studies still say the same thing: Applying manure onto bean ground is a bad idea.

  • It doesn’t make sense agronomically. Soybeans are nitrogen-fixing plants, which means that they can obtain their nitrogen (n) from the air rather than the soil. Because of this trait, soybeans show little or no yield response to applied n. Applying manure or fertilizers reduces the ability of legumes to fix nitrogen, thereby shutting down nature’s own non-polluting “fertilizer plant.”  In the past, DNR staff has said that manure should not be applied to a crop that has the ability to fix its own nitrogen. Clearly, applying manure to ground going into soybeans does not make sense agronomically.
  • It doesn’t make sense economically. Applying manure to fields that are being planted into soybeans is a waste.  Manure contains valuable plant nutrients; however, when applied to legumes such as soybeans, the n component is being wasted. It makes far more economic sense to apply manure to a crop such as corn that responds to applied nitrogen. Manure is being treated as a waste rather than a nutrient when applied to soybeans. Applying manure to land going into soybeans is a waste of natural fertilizer and doesn’t make sense economically.
  • Most importantly, it doesn’t make sense environmentallyData shows that applying manure to soybeans can increase the likelihood of nitrate runoff into Iowa’s streams and rivers.  Nitrogen, a potentially valuable nutrient, becomes a pollutant when excess nitrates flow into our waters.  Iowa already has some of the dirtiest water in the nation, with over 572 on polluted waterways.  Factory farms should not be allowed to apply manure in a way that threatens Iowa’s water quality.

That’s why we are urging the EPC to vote for a ban on the application of manure to fields that are intended for soybeans.  We need sensible practices to clean up Iowa’s endangered waters.  This ban is a step in the right direction and should be followed up with enforceable rules.

 Take action today!

  • Attend the EPC meeting tomorrow to make public comment. Tuesday, October 23 a team of CCI members will meet at the CCI office at 9:30. We’ll head to the EPC meeting together to make public comment and tell them to vote the right way. Public comment is at 10:30. Contact us if you can join us.

Thanks for all you do. We’ll give you a report back soon.


Click LIKE and TWEET if you think applying manure onto bean ground is a bad idea.